I can't even remember what I go down stairs for at work, let alone Halloween when I was 4! Who knows, maybe Dad DID take us out, it would not have been past him, there were only three of us then and such a cute little pack of carrot-tops! After all, we were only 6, 4 and 2, not too much trouble and he would have gotten us home early. All I know is, that Mom DID do Pellie a favor, what a GREAT birthday date!!!! Always a chance to hide as someone else! I am only sorry that dear little Mama missed this one, with a candy-corn witch (what is it with that, one of Evelina's friends did the same witch) and a Star Wars storm trooper, sick or not...